nw-der-review-criteria

定义数据工程产物审查的评分维度与核查要点。

为数据工程产物的审查提供一套可量化的评分维度和核查要点，明确每项审查该看什么、怎么评分，避免凭主观印象给结果打分。例如会检查研究引用是否有据可查、结论是否可追溯等，方便复审时保持一致性并指出具体改进项。适合在代码评审或交付验收时加载使用。

# Data Engineer Review Criteria

Evaluation criteria for each review dimension. Load when performing reviews.

## Dimension 1: Research Citation Quality

Evaluate whether recommendations trace to specific evidence.

**Checks**: Each major recommendation cites a specific research finding | Citations are accurate (finding number matches content) | Vendor-specific claims have multiple independent sources | General best practices distinguished from research-validated guidance

**Scoring**: 10: All cited, verified | 7: Most cited, 1-2 missing on non-critical points | 4: Major recommendations lack citations | 0: No citations

## Dimension 2: Security Coverage

Evaluate defense-in-depth for data la